Bekijk alle reviews

Noctua NF-S12-1200, 120mm Review

+2
Chovav
21 december 2007, laatste update op 21 december 2007, 2.657 views

Noctua NF-S12-1200, 120mm

I did this review in English, if you don't mind, because my Dutch is not that great and it would have taken me ages to finish this review.
About a month ago I bought the Cooler Master Cosmos 1000, which came with 4 12cm ventilators. These ventilators were supposed to be quiet (17dB) but when I connected them to 12V I could hear ticking noises and just noise in general. When I tried connecting them to 5V, the noise production was ok, but they were just not pulling enough air to cool my computer. My hard drives were warm (41 C) and the processor, when fully loaded, was at 57C. You could see the effect of the slow pulling power when letting the processor come back to idle. It took it more than a minute to come back to its base temperature (37 C).
For this reason I decided to buy some new fans. I looked around on Tweakers and saw that everybody was looking at the Noctua fans. So, after contemplating for a while over the price, I decided to buy them. So, 4 fans and 67 euros later, I was the happy owner.
First thing you notice when you get the fans is their unusual design. I kind of like it. The second this is the rubber noise cancelling plugs. I had no clue how to connect the fans with the noise cancelling plugs and because...

Pluspunten

  • * Quiet at 5V
  • * Lots of air movement at 5V and 12V
  • * Interesting design
  • * Long lifetime (according to the website)
  • * No ticking or high pitch sounds

Minpunten

  • * Noise cancelling plugs dont work
  • * There is some noise at 12V
  • * Price is just a bit too high to justify the fans

Eindoordeel

5 van 5 sterren (Uitstekend)
I did this review in English, if you don't mind, because my Dutch is not that great and it would have taken me ages to finish this review.

About a month ago I bought the Cooler Master Cosmos 1000, which came with 4 12cm ventilators. These ventilators were supposed to be quiet (17dB) but when I connected them to 12V I could hear ticking noises and just noise in general. When I tried connecting them to 5V, the noise production was ok, but they were just not pulling enough air to cool my computer. My hard drives were warm (41 C) and the processor, when fully loaded, was at 57C. You could see the effect of the slow pulling power when letting the processor come back to idle. It took it more than a minute to come back to its base temperature (37 C).

For this reason I decided to buy some new fans. I looked around on Tweakers and saw that everybody was looking at the Noctua fans. So, after contemplating for a while over the price, I decided to buy them. So, 4 fans and 67 euros later, I was the happy owner.

First thing you notice when you get the fans is their unusual design. I kind of like it. The second this is the rubber noise cancelling plugs. I had no clue how to connect the fans with the noise cancelling plugs and because there was not manual I had to go to the internet and look for it.

When I found out how, I realized it it almost IMPOSSIBLE to do it. You're supposed to pull the plugs through the case first and then through the fans' holes. It is easy to do the first step, but just impossible to do the second. Especially when you are in a tight spot, like where most fans are situated. The "hook" that has to go through the fans holes is just too big. I couldnt even get it through the fan while trying it outside the case. I really tried but after half an hour I gave up and used the normal bolts.

When I finally had them all installed, I tried to connect the fans to 12V, to see how noisy they were. I had quite high expectations, but learned the fans are not THAT quiet when turning on full blast. It was more or less the same noise level of the cooler master fans (both rated at 17dB), but no ticks or high pitch noises. The amount of air it pushed was unbelievable!

Connecting the fans to 5V did the trick, I couldn't hear ANYTHING, also when putting my ear right next to the fans. They pushed much more air than the cooler master fans, and as I learned later, the pulling power was much greater (you can notice that when the case is closed).

So, after I decided to connect all the fans to 5V, I closed my computer and ran a few tests. Hard drive temperature went down to 32C, a difference of 9C! And for those of you who know the cooler master 1000, there is no direct fan on the hard drive, but the under pressure created by the fans is pulling air through the hard drive cages. This shows the difference in pulling power and thus under preassure that can be created.

The CPU went down to 54C, a difference of 3 degrees. What really showed the difference was that the processor went back to ideal (this time 34C) within 10 seconds, a HUGE difference when comparing that to more than a minute it took before.

So, all in all, I would recommend this fan for those of you who wants alot of air movement at minimal noise, or those of you how don't really mind a bit of noise but really need a small hurricane in their computer. Ohh yeah, and you need to have some money too.

Alle afbeeldingen

Beoordeel deze review: 0 +1 +2 +3

Heb jij ook een Noctua NF-S12-1200, 120mm?

Deel je ervaringen en help andere tweakers!

Schrijf review

Reacties (13)

13
13
0
0
0
12
Wijzig sortering
I did this review in English, if you don't mind,cause my Dutch is not that great and it would have taken me ages to finish this review.

??
Maakt mij verder niet uit, maar je Engels 'is not flawless either, matey!'
Beetje typisch dat je twee maanden geleden nog wel Nederlands kon typen...

[Reactie gewijzigd door bas-r op 26 juli 2024 09:00]

Ik kom oorspronkelijk uit Israel, maar om nu in het Hebreews te gaan schrijven... Als ik dezelfde review in het Nederlands moest gaan schrijven was ik daar veeeeel langer mee bezig. Ik heb nooit gezegd dat mijn Engels "flawless" is. Over mijn vorige review deed ik heel lang, en ik had nog hulp. Dus..... niet zo zeiken.

[Reactie gewijzigd door Chovav op 26 juli 2024 09:00]

"Dus..... niet zo zeiken."

Relax zeg. Ik kan me herinneren dat er hier wel eens complete topics gesloten werden als deze in het Engels waren. Al schrijf je in het Hebreeuws, dat moet je zelf weten. Ik ga mijn punt niet nogmaals maken.

/edit
Oh en als het dan zo nodig in het Engels moet: een Noctua fan is quiet, niet quite. }>

[Reactie gewijzigd door bas-r op 23 juli 2024 11:11]

kijk, daar heb je nog eens opbouwende kritiek :) . Ik wil niet pissig overkomen, het is gewoon veel werk voor mij om iets in het nederlands te gaan schrijven, en mijn vorige review was veel werk. Het is niet alsof ik zomaar vergeten ben hoe ik nederlands moet schrijven.

Sorry, anyway. bedankt voor de kritiek. Ik ga het later misschien nog even vertalen, als mensen dat graag willen.
Nice revieuw
Good readable, but i'm used to conversate in english, so for others i can understand its less useful.

You have an Xilence Cpu cooler? (the red fan just looks like the ones i got to cool my watercooling radiator). :)
reacties kan je wel in het nederlands scrijven.. Ik had gewoon geen zin om uren fouten te zitten wegwerken.

Ja, ik heb een Xilence CPU cooler.. maar denk binnenkort deze te gaan vervangen.. hij koelt niet goed genoeg, vooral als de CPU op 100% is.
Anoniem: 245243 21 december 2007 17:40
Als ik me niet vergis heb je een reepje geheugen in een groene en één in een oranje geheugenbank gestopt. Op deze manier heb je toch geen dualchannel?
in dit moederboard wel.. elke kleur geeft een kanaal aan. twee kleuren = dual channel :)
Weet je dat zeker, dat dacht ik namelijk ook met m'n MSI bord, maar dat is gewoon erg onduidelijk opgeschreven. Daarnaast heb ik nog nooit een bord gezien die op channel 1 en 2 dual channel heeft.

On topic: Ik had jusit gehoord dat er weinig lucht verplaatsins was bij deze fans.
It's okay I prefer Good english so we don't have to read Fuckt-up Dutch...

I have a 4000X2 Boxed and my Temp is ever been higher then 40C, whif 1 case fan (1500rpm)

[Reactie gewijzigd door Roderiktweaker op 26 juli 2024 09:00]

Ik weet het zeker - heb nog even in de handleiding gekeken. Ik heb mijn processor geoverclocked tot 2.5Ghz, daarom is ie warm :)
Hm zijn Engels is misschien niet perfect maar kan me niet voorstellen dat iemand dit niet kan lezen. Ik ga ook eens zoeken naar die Noctua fans.
Where are you from? :P

nice review btw


Om te kunnen reageren moet je ingelogd zijn