Door Wouter Tinus

The production of memory modules at Dane-Elec

06-06-2002 • 18:42

11

Multipage-opmaak

Introduction

Dane-Elec shop aankondigingEarlier this month Tweakers.net had the opportunity to take a look inside the Dane-Elec memory factory in Galway Ireland. Needless to say, we couldn't let this opportunity slip away, and so Femme (founder of Tweakers.net) and Wouter went to Galway to see the place where all of Dane-Elec's memory for the European market is produced.

Before we get into the actual producing process we'll give you a little info about the organization behind Dane-Elec. The company was founded in the year 1985 by the French David Haccoun en Nessim Bodokh, who got to know each other 2 years before, because they worked at the same department. These two guys decided to start for themselves, an started their own company involving alarm systems and passing on all kinds of electronic components. After two years of 'getting to know the market' they decided to specialize in distributing memory for computers.

Dane-Elec fabriek Galway - luchtfoto
Aireal shot of Dane-Elec Galway

Because the process of making memory requires large investments and know-how, they sticked to selling third party components and products. Soon Dane-Elec became a large European distributor for the Japanese brand OKI, but also Samsung and siemens were sold. Their ambition was to make their own memory sticks. And so, in 1996 they opened a factory in Galway. Two years after that they opened a small facility in Irvine, California. This factory however is a lot smaller that the building in Galway

Dane-Elec logoDane-Elec is still managed by David (CEO) and Nessim (COO), from their headquarters in France. Besides managing and selling from France, they also have their Research and Development there. The company has contacts will all the large players in the memory market and went to the stock market in 1997. Because of their success they opened offices in The Netherlands, Belgium, Germany and England. The Irish factory delivers to all the European sellers. The American division of Dane-Elec is independent; the complete production for the American continent is done in California.

The Factory

Galway op de kaart The Irish factory is located near Galway, a city with about 70.000 inhabitants. They have about 140 employees, who work in three shifts to keep the five production lines - divided across a large hall with a size of approximately 2300 square meters - running 24 hours a day 365 days a year. If needed, they can make about 20.000 memory modules a day.

Earlier, this kind of capacity was needed very much to meet demand, and they even thought about expansion for a while. Nowadays the market is a lot less demanding, and because of that, the factory only runs at a 100% around Christmas. A factory like this does not use mass production. You can order dozens of different types of modules. The software the machinery uses can be changed within a few minutes to use different PCB's or components. They made hundreds of these programs for all kinds of different memory chips and components - ranging from EDO-SIMM to RDRAM.

The latter one is not produced in Galway. The testing equipment for RDRAM is very expensive, and because there is a relatively low demand for RDRAM, Dane-Elec decided to buy this kind of memory somewhere else and to just distribute it. Products like cardreaders and Smartmedia cards follow the same principle as RDRAM.

Voorkant Dane-Elec fabriek

Besides the large range of products and the security of the warehouse there is another important argument not to work with large stocks. Money. The prices on the memory chips market are, as everybody knows, strongly under the influence of fluctuating prices. To keep the damage to a minimum they buy their products 'on-spot'. Various companies - i.e. Toshiba, Samsung and Infineon - store their chips in a large vault within the Dane-Elec factory. Although the memory is ready to use, it remains property of the companies mentioned above. As soon as an order arrives at Dane-Elec for modules and the chips are removed from the vault for production, the actual transfer takes place for the, at that moment, going price. The advantage of this is, that the modules can profit directly from price changes.

Dane-Elec productiehal
An impression of the production hall

Dane-Elec fabriek van binnen #2
Productionline number 2

Dane-Elec is not (yet) that big to make their own chips, and they don’t have a real 'cleanroom' like Intel or AMD use to place their wafferscanners. But they do try to keep the production room as clean and dust free as possible. This is to prevent that dust particles ruin a memory module by creating a faulty contact. Static electricity is another problem for the plant. Every desk has anti-static on it and everybody who wishes to enter the plant has to use a special jacket and an ankle-bracelet to ground themselves.

Wouter als semi-astronaut

Preparing the PCB's

How the orders are processed here in Galway will be explained in the next few pages using a lot of visual material. Unfortunately it was impossible to take a picture of every little detail in the plant. Part of the equipment was labeled top-secret. Sadly to say, but in this industry people introduce themselves as potential buyer, seller or journalist to find out what kind of testing equipment Dane-Elec uses or to find out how Dane-Elec manages to produce their ComplactFlash memory so fast. That is why all the pictures we wanted to bring home from the plant had to be screened by the head of production.

Bedrijfspionage in progress
Femme taking a peek

Back to ordering. An order exists out of 5 to 2000 modules. These can be different types of modules. Larger orders are split up into work orders of 2000 modules per order. This first step is to collect the necessary components from the warehouse. Think of PCB's, resistors, chips etc.

The PCB's are then placed into a feeder, which sends them to a screen printer. This printer uses a very precise pump mechanism, controlled by a special camera, to stamp the correct pattern of soldering paste on the PCB. This has to be done before any components are placed on the PCB's, because they stopped using PCB's with holes in the bottom which can be soldered eons ago. The paste in raw form is a very toxic gray mass, but also very expensive because it (amongst others substances) has silver in it. This is not only good for looks, but also good for conduction.

Dane-Elec screen printer
The screen printer - in the reflection you can see where the PCB's are supposed to be
Dane-Elec trip: Soldeerprut
Solder paste
Dane-Elec trip: EDO reepjes uit screenprinter
This is where the wannabe-modules come out

The PCB's go to a Philips Sapphire Machine through a conveyor belt. This machine can put a small component on 6 PCB's in less that a second. The robot arm is fed by special rolls and can hold 24 different types of small components. The computer that controls the robot arm on the sapphire machine relies on information from a high-resolution 10x zoom camera, to put the components in the correct place.

Dane-Elec - Sapphire
Sapphire in all it's 1337-ness

Dane-Elec - Sapphire
The inside of the machine

Dane-Elec - Sapphire
The moving robot arm with 24 heads

Dane-Elec - Sapphire
One of the highly sensitive camera's

Dane-Elec: Sapphire
Supplying parts to the machine

Dane-Elec: Sapphire
The mechanism that takes the resistors from the roll to the machine

Dane-Elec: Sapphire
No shortage here…

Mounting the memory chips

The Sapphire machine mentioned on the previous page can only put small parts onto the PCB. The Topaz machine is used to put the bigger parts onto the PCB. This machine is also a Philips-product like the Sapphire. The basic construction of both machines is very similar. The difference between them is that the Topaz can handle parts accurate to 32 millimeter (memory chips) due to a intelligent system which is called: on-the-fly vision alignment. With the help of small movable cameras this machine can handle smaller parts but the Sapphire is preferred to handle this task. The latter one does about 24.500 units per hour while the Topaz does 'only' a mere 14.000 in the same time.

Dane-Elec - Glimmend schoon
Every piece of equipment is kept very clean
Dane-Elec trip: Ethan (?) met rolletje chips
The memory chips a packed on large rolls
Dane-Elec - Rol geheugen
...and are individually packaged as well
Dane-Elec trip: Philips Topaz monitor
For every type of module a different program has to be loaded

When every part is in the right place the moment of baking the chip starts. The chips are put into the oven. Dane-Elec prefers to call it: computerized thermal processing system. The oven has to do the following; vaporize a part of the paste, melt another part of it and finally harden a part of the paste again on the PCB. In the end all the placed parts have to be stuck on their mounted spot. Very high temperatures are needed in this process. Overclockers can tell you that only a few processors will survive temperatures higher than 100 degrees Celsius, but the memory chips have to withstand temperatures almost three times higher in the oven.

Dane-Elec trip: Wouter bakt reepjes
The oven
Dane-Elec: oven
To use the entire width of the oven, the computer can move the conveyor belt

Dane-Elec: oven
Fingerguards, but probably not your average 80 x 80 fan

Dane-Elec: oven
For people who do not understand that things in an oven get hot

The manufacturer of the memory chips develops a model in cooperation with the supplier of the welding paste. This model is designed in such a way that the chips can be welded in the oven without breaking down. The chips can withstand temperatures of over 270 degrees Celsius two times in a row. The reason for this is that double sided memory has to pass the production line twice.

Dane-Elec : temperatuur-configuratie
Temperature configuration of the oven

When the modules leave the oven they are put into a feeder on the other end of the production line. Lamps indicate if there is still place available otherwise it indicates it's time to empty the feeder. The distance the PCB totally covers is 20 meters from on end to the other end of the feeder. The finished modules are immediately sterilizedand labeled.

Dane-Elec trip: opvangkast aan eind productielijn
Endstation

CompactFlash

Although the larger portion of the plant is designed to make SDRAM and DDR memory, the demand for Compactflash is increasing. Especially the demand in Holland is getting bigger and bigger. Us Dutchies are a pain in the ass' according to the people who work there . We want special retail boxes, while stores in other countries don�t see the need for it or the do it themselves.

Lading 256MB Cf kaartjes voor Nederland
Bunch of 256 MB CompactFlash cards in neat little boxes for the Dutch Market
Voorspelling flash verkoop
Expected growth in the world market for flashcards

The basics of making CompactFlash memory are not so different from the method to make SDRAM or DDR memory. The PCB is suited for 5 memory chips and one controller. The reason the controller is on the PCB and not the machine that uses the CompactFlash memory, is that support for faster and bigger is easier to realize.

Dane-Elec Flash
CompactFlash PCB's
Dane-Elec Flash
Chips for the CompactFlash PCB
Dane-Elec Flash
CompactFlash machine
Dane-Elec Flash
Enough storage for a few vacation shots

Once the PCB is ready, it has to be placed in the well known housing. This housing is delivered as 2 separate half�s and are welded together with the help of ultrasonic vibrations. Other manufacturers use a system where the housing folds together like a little box. Once the compactFlash has its housing, they are ready to be tested.

Resistance is futile. You will be slashdotted. ;)

http://slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=02/06/07/004246&mode=nested&tid=126
Anoniem: 29158 @[ti]7 juni 2002 09:46
never underastemate the power of l33t ./ beating servers :p
Anoniem: 32081 7 juni 2002 09:29
Dit soort verhalen mogen wat mij betreft vaker verschijnen. Het geeft een mooi overzicht wat zich afspeelt bij het produceren van electronica onderdelen. Mooie foto's trouwens ook, best wel opmerkelijk dat er zoveel gefotografeerd mocht worden, zelfs bij screening van de foto's. Niet alle fabrikanten laten dit toe en zijn alleen bereid om hun eigen PR materiaal te overhandigen. Knap werk dus. :)
Dane ontvangt van ons een CD met de high-res foto's voor... PR-doeleinden :D
Wow, mooi artikel, Wouter, kudos! En de huidige top story op /.. Verder sluit ik me helemaal aan bij de opmerkingen van plok.

Ik heb een klein weergave probleem. Apostrofs (') worden als een blokje weergegeven en je gebruikt een aantal keren een apostrof bij meervoudsvormen als camera's en PCB's; dat hoeft niet in het Engels. Misschien kan je dat nog even fixen?
Wat een stel sneue gasten die daar op /. reageren op het artikel alsof T.net niks is. Nahaj, wij weten beter. Bovendien is dit een van de weinige sites waar Linux en Windows freaks nog enigszins goed naast elkaar weten te leven... /. is toch meer een linux-site en dan gaan de users daaro afgeven op de 'multi-culti' opzet van T.net... triest...

Goed artikel, trek jullie vooral niks aan van die slashdotters...
Anoniem: 26065 7 juni 2002 23:13
Niet zeikerig bedoeld (echt niet), maar het is to stick, stuck, stuck en niet "sticked" zoals in de opening te lezen is (they sticked to...).

Voor de rest prima artikel. Jullie zijn trouwens gelinkt van DPReview, zo kwam ik weer hier :-).
Anoniem: 14842 15 juni 2002 16:20
Erg leuk verslag jongens, maar dat zullen jullie zelf ook wel gevonden hebben :P

Als jullie zelf wat meer reviews en artikels schrijven word T.net denk ik vanzelf nog drukker. De kwaliteit is in elk geval aanwezig!

:)
cheerio, well done dudes.
gaaf verslag, erg leuk om te lezen. Wel stoer dat ze t.net uitnodigen in ierland :)

Op dit item kan niet meer gereageerd worden.