Je kunt Intel en AMD modellen helaas niet zomaar met elkaar vergelijken.
van silentpcreview:
How does AMD define TDP?
“Thermal Design Power (TDP) is measured under the conditions of TCASE Max, IDD Max, and VDD=VID_VDD, and include all power dissipated on-die from VDD, VDDIO, VLDT, VTT, and VDDA.”
This means that TDP, as defined by AMD, is measured at the maximum current the CPU can draw, at the default voltage, under the worst-case temperature conditions. This is the maximum power that the CPU can possibly dissipate. Intel, however, has a different definition.
How does Intel define TDP?
From the Intel Datasheet for Northwood CPUs:
“The numbers in this column reflect Intel’s recommended design point and are not indicative of the maximum power the processor can dissipate under worst case conditions.”
And from Intel’s datasheet for Prescott CPUs:
“Thermal Design Power (TDP) should be used for processor thermal solution design targets. The TDP is not the maximum power that the processor can dissipate.”
And the most telling quote of all, contained in both documents:
“Analysis indicates that real applications are unlikely to cause the processor to consume maximum power dissipation for sustained periods of time. Intel recommends that complete thermal solution designs target the Thermal Design Power (TDP) indicated in Table 26 instead of the maximum processor power consumption. The Thermal Monitor feature is intended to help protect the processor in the unlikely event that an application exceeds the TDP recommendation for a sustained period of time.”
What this means is that Intel’s TDP is actually lower than the maximum power dissipation of the processor (and as you’ll see later, it can be significantly lower). This is in stark contrast to AMD’s TDP numbers, which are higher than the respective processor’s maximum power dissipation.
Herberekende cijfers voor Pentium M:
//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
Intel Pentium M (Dothan), 0.09 micron, 2048 kByte Level 2 cache
CPUID=06D6h, B1 revision, 100 MHz DAR QDR FSB
Vcc down & Static Max. down - 0.003V/A
Target design point: 25A
FULL SPEED MODE:
VID=1.340V parts / 0.988V battery (Classic Models)
--------------------------------------------------
21A * 1.277V = 26.817W 2.00 GHz
21A * 1.277V = 26.817W 1.80 GHz
21A * 1.277V = 26.817W 1.70 GHz
Bij dit soort kleine verschillen is de keuze van het moederbord waarschijnlijk belangrijker voor de stroomrekening dan de keuze tussen de beide processors.